Débora Yuk từ Etcharry, France

deborayuk

12/22/2024

Dữ liệu người dùng, đánh giá và đề xuất cho sách

Débora Yuk Sách lại (10)

2019-11-05 19:30

Đồng Tiền Hai Mặt Thư viện Sách hướng dẫn

Sách được viết bởi Bởi: Nguyễn Khắc Mẫn

** spoiler alert ** Ah, CLAMP. Your artwork is absolutely GORGEOUS, especially in this book. It has PAGES of CLAMP’s gorgeous, detailed artwork in COLOUR, and I freely admit to being way too distracted by that. If you like CLAMPs art and the combination of simple layout and detailed accessories/art, this might be relevant to your interests. The character designs are lovely by the way - Sue, Ora and Gingetsu have my favourite designs of anyone in the manga, and the weaponry designs are fantastic. The story is told backwards, which makes more sense than it seems it should - the first two volumes deal with Sue and her journey, the third with Ora before that, and the last with Ran even before that. My favourite story arc has to be Ora’s, I’ll admit - she is my favourite character, just because she’s got a dream, and she’s got things that she loves and make her happy and regardless of what’s going to happen and when, she is going to live her life and her dream and enjoy it. She is my favourite. I would have loved to see more about the mystery plot that’s touched upon involving her as well - the plot of the main storyline doesn’t interest as much as that would. SPOILER, highlight to read: Although it IRKS ME TO ALL HELL that she is fridged. Although actually, I’m not sure whether it’s actually fridging at this point? She doesn’t seem to provide that much motivation for her boyfriend as it does for Sue - it seems more to be a motivation for Ora herself? It just annoys me that she’s killed and then it’s never explained, we don’t get to see it being investigated, NOTHING. Annoying. Also, as an aside, CLAMP! I see you are keeping up your trend of having the relationships be a touch on the creepy side - Sue is a tiny girl who appears to be about twelve or thirteen (there is no proof that she is or isn’t, because apparently the place she and Ran lived halted their aging and accelerate it should they leave, which really DOESN’T HELP ANYTHING because Ran looks about six in his origin story and is said to only have around five years to live, and Ran doesn’t look that much older, and - well, there is love and suggestions that some of these relationships are intimate and my brain is still flagging this as creepy. ... On the other hand, still not as creepy as the guy who seems to want to kill Kazuhiko and keep his corpse for um. Personal use. Um. BASICALLY, this is CLAMP being CLAMP in its usual “pretty but not necessarily wholesome mode,” and just. Yes. If you have read and enjoyed CLAMP you will probably enjoy this! As an aside, if this is relevant to your interests, might I also recommend Stigma by Kazuya Minekura [GoodReads] - it’s the artist of Saiyuki doing a full colour manga that ALSO involves a bitter man guarding a small child on a journey and possibly loving them inappropriately, with 100% fewer girls with wings and equal amounts of creepy nemeses who seem to want to have sex with the hero, kill the hero and possibly do both of these things at EXACTLY THE SAME TIME. It is beautiful and about as messed up as you expect.) (ORIGINALLY REVIEWED AS PART OF A GUEST POST AT LADY BUSINESS.)

Người đọc Débora Yuk từ Etcharry, France

Người dùng coi những cuốn sách này là thú vị nhất trong năm 2017-2018, ban biên tập của cổng thông tin "Thư viện Sách hướng dẫn" khuyến cáo rằng tất cả các độc giả sẽ làm quen với văn học này.